| · Terms of use · Portal |
Help
Search
Members
Calendar
|
| Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register ) | Resend Validation Email |
![]() ![]() |
| Conway |
Posted: Aug 26 2008, 10:41 PM
|
![]() Administrator ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 12,629 Member No.: 1 Joined: 16-May 03 |
The final results, after 27 weeks of round robin match-ups, are as follows:
Rank - Album Title - Points 1. Hex Enduction Hour - 64 2. Perverted By Language - 63 3. Grotesque - 58 4. Slates - 57 5. This Nation's Saving Grace - 53 6. Dragnet - 46 7. The Real New Fall LP Formerly C.O.T.C. - 44 8. The Wonderful And Frightening World Of... - 42 9. The Unutterable - 40 10. Bend Sinister - 39 11. Room To Live - 33 12. The Frenz Experiment - 31 13. The Infotainment Scan - 28 14. Live At The Witch Trials - 27 15. Extricate - 26 16. Fall Heads Roll - 21 17. I Am Kurious Oranj - 20 18. Levitate - 18 19. Code: Selfish - 16 20. The Light User Syndrome - 16 21. Shift-Work - 13 22. The Marshall Suite - 10 23. Middle Class Revolt - 8 24. Cerebral Caustic - 6 25. Reformation Post TLC - 4 26. Are You Are Missing Winner - 2 27. Seminal Live - 0 (19 & 20 are ranked by votes differential) The full points table is here. -------------------- New members - please read the "terms of use" of the forum, see link at top left of page. And please check the index of past topics in each section before you ask a question that may have been asked previously. Thanks! If anyone is having any technical problems with the forum, please email me at conwaypaton@gmail.com Profile the next studio album |
| twinz2z |
Posted: Aug 26 2008, 10:57 PM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 7,344 Member No.: 4,007 Joined: 26-July 07 |
Many thank's to Conway for a job well done, not a single glitch as far as I can remember.
It's interesting to note the most 'Bonus' win matches go's to, Perverted-13 Hex-12 Slate's-11 Grotesque-10, --------------- It might be an idea to have The Final Point's table easily accesible somewhere, for when new-comer's ask for a good place to start buying album's. -------------------- ;Just like people
What does it all mean, Q. Its about Time? ------------------------------------------- "Lieutenant Decker"--'It takes you no time to get there!' 'Where?' 'The here and now,--you need the concept of "No Time" 'Oh I see' Do not suffer fools. "Junctures between dimensions in time are freaks of nature; that happen" |
| Mere Pseud. |
Posted: Aug 26 2008, 11:05 PM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 5,871 Member No.: 1,870 Joined: 29-June 05 |
Thanks a lot for your massive efforts, Conway.
It's been a lot of fun and ended with a (rather unexpected) gripping outcome on top. -------------------- Mind moving fast is mad. Mind moving slow is sane.
|
| spiring |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 01:25 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 2,333 Member No.: 500 Joined: 14-January 04 |
I can't really complain about the results, all my Top 6 albums (neither HEH nor PBL are among them) are in the Top 9. In other words, my tastes are pretty average, it seems.
-------------------- Your choice is fish. Be drinkable.
"An nescis, mi fili, quantilla prudentia mundus regatur" |
| Buy Kurious! |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 01:40 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 16,904 Member No.: 2,718 Joined: 25-March 06 |
Thanks, Conway.
![]() I can't argue with the top 4...the rest fluctuate for me over time... -------------------- |
| mixstreams |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 04:41 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 527 Member No.: 5,160 Joined: 22-February 08 |
so that's the end of that matter...
hang on. are you lot sure frenz is better than light user syndrome? -------------------- "Erotic, romantic, comic and horrific enough to loosen the bowels of a bronze statue", Christopher Lee
|
| Country Folk |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 04:49 AM
|
![]() Worse than a woman ![]() Group: Members Posts: 1,842 Member No.: 505 Joined: 21-January 04 |
Shame Shiftwork couldn't have made it a bit higher.
Still, the league was fun & can't really argue with the winner (or Missing Winner) -------------------- |
| 799thJim |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 05:59 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 994 Member No.: 2,734 Joined: 29-March 06 |
Meh, less to look forward to now
-------------------- "Many have found pleasures in curvaceous women,
Their undulating curves upper and lower, But what I really need is a glass of cold water" |
| Bat Masterson |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 06:50 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 112 Member No.: 5,164 Joined: 22-February 08 |
Thanks for wasting hours of my life over the past months! Not being sarcastic here; thanks for all the hard work.
|
| snoweyuk |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 06:59 AM
|
![]() Live At The Tree Line ![]() Group: Members Posts: 4,680 Member No.: 3,135 Joined: 5-November 06 |
Yeah, Well done Conway. Its very nice to see the final table, which must be the closest anyone has ever got to a meaningful ranking of the Gruppe's studio LPs, from a fan's point of view.
Looks about right I guess, though PBL, WAFW, and Levitate are placed higher in this list than in mine. I personally think LATWT, Cerebral Caustic and AYAMW are better than their final placings too. Otherwise, I'd say my own opinions are broadly the same as the majority. Very entertaining event -------------------- ![]() Burrows |
| Hanley Played a Fender P |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 07:04 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 2,659 Member No.: 1,578 Joined: 15-March 05 |
Look Back Bore Fest.
Cheers for all the effort Conway, but compared to recent live performances (2006 -2008, and then mainly the Yanks apart from Cardiff, Newcastle and Bloomberg), the first 5 or 5 albums are better than sleeping pills. ![]() OK, I'll give you Classical. And Winter. But that's it alright. -------------------- Hanleyvision™ http://www.youtube.com/user/hanleyfender
XX Hanleyfender. Joining the long long tradition of Saddo's XX "Hold your fire, hold your fire. Remember you are provincial fucking scum". MES Worthing 1996 |
| Dktr Hohnholz-G |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 08:12 AM
|
|
members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 849 Member No.: 13 Joined: 18-May 03 |
Can't really argue against the top ten.
Its a shame about the low showing of The Marshall Suite, Middle Class Revolt Are You Are Missing Winner. Its a real shame about Reformation Post TLC. The U.S. version is a cracker. Maybe next poll. |
| Kapitän |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 08:33 AM
|
||
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 3,032 Member No.: 3,316 Joined: 3-February 07 |
I was just about to post more or less the same thing. Wished those 3 (and Frenz) were much higher up, WAFWOTF should be considerably further down - apart from that the list look allright-ish to me... -------------------- Owner of dogs, slow-witted dog owner.
It takes grace to play the second fiddle well |
||
| DeusErac |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 12:51 PM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 73 Member No.: 3,895 Joined: 22-June 07 |
I don't post much, but I do vote in all these contents. For my two cents . . .
No surprises in the top five, or the number one. I think that Dragnet, Witch Trials and Infotainment Scan are all over-rated. RNFLP shoulda finished higher. Shift-Work and Middle Class Revolt are surprisingly (and woefully) under-appreciated. Nice work in managing such a long-term, data-intensive poll! |
| Divvey |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 09:24 PM
|
![]() Forgotten but not gone ![]() Group: Members Posts: 13,769 Member No.: 411 Joined: 6-December 03 |
1. Hex Enduction Hour - 64
2. Perverted By Language - 63 3. Grotesque - 58 4. Slates - 57 5. This Nation's Saving Grace - 53 6. Dragnet - 46 7. The Real New Fall LP Formerly C.O.T.C. - 44 8. The Wonderful And Frightening World Of... - 42 9. The Unutterable - 40 10. Bend Sinister - 39[QUOTE] That's pretty much my top 10. Glad you all agree with me. -------------------- Save money; write your own books.
|
| Frederick II |
Posted: Aug 27 2008, 09:51 PM
|
![]() Great White Dope ![]() Group: Members Posts: 5,826 Member No.: 3,864 Joined: 14-June 07 |
Yes, cheers Conway and the team. A very absorbing contest, even if I am disappointed - but hardly surprised - by the final results.
-------------------- YAREEPWOTUSO
One part the Fuhrer, one part the Pope |
| killerpup |
Posted: Aug 28 2008, 03:04 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 663 Member No.: 5,171 Joined: 23-February 08 |
FYI on the other thread Conway said he was going to do a 2-week cup--IWS against everyone--so it's not quite over yet.
I think it was a blast. Sure I wish certain albums finished higher but whatever. You can't have 27 albums in the top 10 unfortunately. Also funny, because lots of people here seem bored with the standard Hex, Slates, etc. being the top albums. But only recently coming here, all I ever heard from the outside world--those that even heard of the Fall, allmusic, review sites, etc.--is that the 80s were the best. Wonderful, Grace, Bend, Frenz, A-Sides. They were the best, the rest is just weird. Insiders perspective favors 1980-83 as the top. Hard to argue. Now that we geniuses have this "definitive" list how 'bout our top 10 vs...say Rolling Stones top 10 all time albums? (kidding--we all know who'd win anyway -------------------- "And deep down, inside, you know...everybody wants to like big companies."
|
| Sudost36 |
Posted: Aug 28 2008, 03:51 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 1,090 Member No.: 64 Joined: 9-June 03 |
Missed the last two weeks voting due to holiday and broken down laptop, but thanks for organising the cup Conway.
Well done to Killerpup for your unending promotion of RNFLP. I'm sure your efforts helped it gain it's top 10 finish. |
| Mopiranger |
Posted: Aug 28 2008, 05:03 AM
|
![]() Fingerpainting in the leper colony ![]() Group: Members Posts: 3,934 Member No.: 4,087 Joined: 17-August 07 |
Curious about Imperial Wax Solvent next year. Grotesque - I don't see it. I'll be voting more rigourously next time. Thanks!
-------------------- |
| a la bowie |
Posted: Aug 28 2008, 07:22 AM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 1,451 Member No.: 1,866 Joined: 27-June 05 |
Great stuff Conway, it was a fine diversion from all the Fall-related chatter on here.
-------------------- |
| Conway |
Posted: Aug 28 2008, 09:53 AM
|
![]() Administrator ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 12,629 Member No.: 1 Joined: 16-May 03 |
Thanks for the thanks everyone. I'll get the first lot of Imperial Wax Solvent polls up and running tonight.
-------------------- New members - please read the "terms of use" of the forum, see link at top left of page. And please check the index of past topics in each section before you ask a question that may have been asked previously. Thanks! If anyone is having any technical problems with the forum, please email me at conwaypaton@gmail.com Profile the next studio album |
| Nail Soup |
Posted: Aug 29 2008, 07:06 PM
|
![]() members ![]() Group: Members Posts: 102 Member No.: 1,645 Joined: 11-April 05 |
Thanks for the poll Conway!
Hey, Grotesque fans - think it should have been number one? Well, it had the best vote difference, so it sorta kinda maybe was? |
![]() |
![]() ![]() |